Standard & Poor's lowered its long-term counterparty credit and insurer financial strength ratings on Aviva Insurance Europe SE (Aviva SE) to 'A-' from 'A+'. The ratings remain on CreditWatch with negative implications, where they were placed on Nov. 25, 2010, following the downgrade and CreditWatch placement of the Republic of Ireland.
The rating action follows S&P's consideration that it is less likely that Aviva plc (Aviva; A/Negative) will consolidate certain of its material European operations into Ireland-based Aviva SE in 2011.
Furthermore, on Feb. 2, 2011, the Republic of Ireland was downgraded to 'A-/A-2' from 'A/A-1' and remains on CreditWatch with negative implications.
"Under our ratings criteria, sovereign risk is a key factor influencing the financial strength of insurers," S&P credit analyst Tatiana Grineva says. "As a result, the vast majority of insurers are rated no higher than the relevant sovereign local currency rating. Consequently, we have lowered the ratings on Aviva SE by two notches to reflect the increasing sovereign-related risk."
Prior to today's rating action S&P assumed that Aviva would increasingly operate its European general insurance business through European branches of Aviva SE, diluting the current level of business and financial exposure to Irish sovereign risk within this rated legal entity. S&P now believes that in the near term Aviva SE's business profile will remain largely focused on Irish risks.
The CreditWatch placement follows the CreditWatch action on Ireland and reflects the possibility that S&P may lower the ratings following its review of Aviva SE's exposure to heightened sovereign-related risks. The ratings on Aviva SE could also be lowered if the agency were to lower the ratings on Ireland further, but are likely to remain in the investment-grade category.
AXA Insurance Ltd.
S&P placed its 'BBB+' long-term counterparty credit and insurer financial strength ratings on AXA Insurance Ltd. (AXA) on CreditWatch with negative implications.
On Feb. 2, 2011, S&P lowered its ratings on the Republic of Ireland to A-/Watch Neg/A-2 from A/Watch Neg/A-1. Under the firm's ratings criteria, it only rates insurance companies higher than the sovereign under specific circumstances. Although S&P factors in support for AXA based on its membership of the AXA group, the limit that the sovereign effectively places on the rating supersedes the implied group support.
S&P understands that AXA has no exposure to Irish government bonds. Hence, it believes movements in the sovereign rating do not directly affect the quality of the company's investment portfolio.
The CreditWatch placement follows that on Ireland and reflects the possibility of a further downgrade. If S&P lowers the sovereign credit ratings by two notches or more, to below AXA's current 'BBB+' level, the firm would also lower the ratings on AXA so that they were in alignment with the sovereign. In the wake of the Feb. 2, 2011, rating action, S&P considers such a development to be a realistic possibility. Consequently, S&P considers it appropriate to place the AXA rating on CreditWatch with negative implications. That said, S&P would currently expect the ratings on both Ireland and AXA to remain in the investment-grade category over the rating horizon.
Everest Insurance Company of Canada
A.M. Best assigned a financial strength rating of A+ (Superior) and an issuer credit rating of "aa-" to Everest Insurance Company of Canada (EvCan). The outlook assigned to both ratings is stable.
EvCan will conduct business in Canada, which is licensed to write property, automobile, surety, liability and other classes of insurance on a primary basis. The company will be capitalized with approximately CAD 50 million in common equity and is ultimately owned by the Everest Re Group Ltd (Everest).
The assigned ratings reflect EvCan's solid capitalization, expected operating results, reasonable business plan and a management team that is familiar with the business lines. The company's planned business is supported by a quota share agreement with Everest Reinsurance Co., along with financial, enterprise risk management and corporate governance oversight from Everest. EvCan's ratings also meet A.M. Best's strict start-up capitalization requirements, which mandate a more conservative level of risk-based capital to support its ratings.
Farm Bureau Life Insurance Co.
S&P assigned its 'A-' counterparty credit and financial strength ratings on Farm Bureau Life Insurance Co. and EquiTrust Life Insurance Co. (FBL group). At the same time, S&P assigned a 'BBB-' counterparty credit rating on FBL Financial Group Inc. The outlook is stable.
"The ratings reflect FBL group's strong competitive position in its target markets," says credit analyst Patrick Wong. "By leveraging its close relationship with the Farm Bureau and its property/casualty counterpart, FBL has significantly expanded its presence in farm communities."
Farm Bureau Life offers traditional life insurance and annuity products in 15 Midwestern and western states. EquiTrust Life offers fixed and indexed annuities to urban areas in 49 states. "In addition, FBL group's operating performance is strong, as it has been steadily improving after significantly weakening in 2008," Wong says. "Farm Bureau Life has steadily contributed stable earnings, while EquiTrust has provided earnings growth opportunities." Investment portfolio quality has remained high despite a modest drop in industry-wide investment portfolio quality. Asset/liability management has improved with the annuity segment and is very well matched.